Healthcare Quarterly
Abstract
Susan was Chief Financial Officer for The Toronto Hospital, and at the time of the merger in 1997 she was the Chief Operating Officer for Princess Margaret, which she had joined in 1991. Prior to this, Susan was an executive with Diversicare Corporation of America, working in Tennessee and Toronto, and with Price Waterhouse. She is a graduate of Wilfrid Laurier University with a BBA, and earned her Chartered Accountant designation in 1981. Susan is actively involved in professional and fundraising activities. Her peers recently honoured her by awarding her a fellowship (FCA) of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Ontario. She is a member of the Board of Directors of CARE Canada and is currently a board Vice-President.
I'm responsible for a $349 million redevelopment project to be completed by end of calendar 2004, so that keeps me really busy. I'm constantly meeting with architects or site administration people, and I'm the public relations champion of the project, keeping colleagues up to date on progress. I'm also responsible for some large hospital programs and six departments - all facilities, plant operations, security, nutrition (patient clinical/retail), all retail leasing, medical engineering, plus any facility renewal. I'm not hands-on, as I certainly have capable directors, but I'm front and centre and have to keep it all going.
You're said to meet construction targets, yet we often hear
of effects such as delays, work slowdowns or lack of skilled
workers. How do you keep to time lines?
We have to have the best project team and follow a schedule in
sufficient enough detail that it can constantly be monitored. If
we're going off schedule we have to have a flexible contingency
plan. We had a concrete strike last June and lost six weeks, when
phase two was obviously contingent upon completion of that phase.
The contractor worked around the strike and was able to work with
our team to minimize impact. So, we've found that good construction
management services are key to keeping things moving. We have five
phases at both the Toronto General (TG) and Toronto Western (TW)
sites and neither is a green field site, which is the ideal. Yet,
we made a commitment to the government that we wouldn't be down for
even one day, so we had to move patients and plan well.
Architect Raymond Moriyama said he couldn't live in a house
he designed, as he'd want to make changes to it. Do you walk
through the halls and watch how people use or don't use
space?
It's really tough and so true, because I always see where I can
make improvements. The Princess Margaret (PM) redevelopment was
breathtaking on Day One, and yet I also knew there were things we
could have done better. What's more of a challenge at TG and TW is
that they've suffered from a decade of no funds being spent on
them. I walk through the halls and see all kinds of things that
need to be done.
As for how people use space, we had an interesting example at the PM site. We'd put new chairs into a patient area where we assumed that they would be used in small groupings, but the patients put the chairs in rows so they can watch everyone who comes in. There is also not the respect there once was for public property, as with the Elizabeth Street entrance at TG - people walk across the front lawn instead of using sidewalks. Now that we have smokers outside, it has an impact on the look and function of all public places. It's difficult to keep the areas clean, and there are constantly smokers at entrances.
Hospitals have gone through a decade of cuts, and there's been real demoralization of staff, but I think we're in a period of renewal for both the staff and public. My staff and the site VPs are working to develop improvements over time and encourage a culture of respect.
How are you preserving the important historical and valued
aspects of the older buildings?
We removed the old Bell entrance at TG, and it's being preserved
and stored so that it can eventually be reinstated in the patient
court in the clinical services building on the fourth floor. It
will be blended with the new and will be magnificent. All inpatient
units will overlook the glass atrium. We've also taken a complete
inventory of all artefacts, and where possible pieces will be
reinstated in the new buildings, as we've already done in the
emergency area with a stained glass window. As well, a statue of
Edith Cavell will be integrated into the new front entrance on
University Avenue in the atrium. The museum, with some 4,000
catalogued artefacts, will be displayed on rotation in all three
sites.
We assume plans will improve patient care and staff
contentment, but what's new with access, parking and
wayfinding?
We've engaged a prominent wayfinding consultant. We looked at how
to get to each facility and what's the easiest way to identify
where a person is going and how to get there. We have a wayfinding
strategy, such as reducing the number of main entrances and
improving patient drop-offs, and parking will be increased at both
sites. We're organizing patient activity in buildings so surgical,
ambulatory, diagnostic and inpatient units are consolidated. This
in itself will be a big improvement. At the TG site, there'll be
underground parking, which doesn't exist now, and another 530
parking spaces in the Elizabeth Street garage. We'll also have a
main street direct through the campus from Elizabeth Street to
University Avenue and will no longer need tunnels. Glass bridges
and glass elevators will connect buildings, and what's really new
is the patient court. At the TW, the open courtyards were wasted
space, but now a great patient visitor atrium will complete the
flow by direct routes, the same as with TG.
The UHN was the first hospital in Canada to secure capital
market financing for a public/private partnership, giving $281
million of a $349 million total. What downsides were
discussed?
The biggest concern was committing a public institution to a
25-year repayment plan. The funding was wonderful, but we are
committing funds and that scares people, as it's never been done
here. Payments are certain, but funding is not certain. In my 12
years in the hospital sector, funding has never been predictable.
It's also difficult managing the expectations of 8,000 staff. It
was hard for some people to understand why we borrowed funds to
build. Of course, we understand there should be more money for
staff, but funding for building development is separate and this
was part of our communications to staff.
So what did you play with as a kid - Lincoln Logs, Lego - and
did you ace Grade One math?
I played school and had dolls, but yes I was always great at math.
When I was in Grade 13, I took mostly math - four courses - so I
could get into the best schools. It took discipline.
How does your sense of humour improve the
workplace?
In spite of being a CA, I believe humour is always needed. If you
can turn a situation around with humour, it eases the tension.
Healthcare can be so serious, but we can lighten it up.
How do you ensure you plan for new trends and
technology?
Within UHN, we have an excellent medical engineering group and we
are affiliated with the University of Toronto, so leading-edge
thinking is already in-house. A full-time director from our
information technology group is integrated with my project team, so
with the medical design team, we've gone out of our way to get the
best to coordinate these demands.
How do you go from a COO/CFO to being in charge of
redevelopment - isn't this usually an architect's or planner's
role?
Yes it is, but as I was immersed in the $225 million project at PM,
and since the project was the building of a small hospital, I had
the benefit of being involved in everything. It was my
responsibility to manage it, and I was integrated with medical
people and learned how a hospital functions at every level. I
learned how important it is to bring clinicians, nurses and all
professionals to the table. With my financial skills, I was
conscious of budgeting. With that overview, I also know when
something is fundamentally wrong with a patient process.
What buildings in Canada do you think work in all respects -
from initial design or perhaps renovation - considering user and
worker needs?
For public buildings, I think Toronto's BCE Place is spectacular in
the way that it incorporates the old with the new. I also like the
Royal Ontario Museum, especially with its new plans. Historical
merit is very important to me - blending the old with the new. We
looked to the United States - Chicago, New York and California -
for examples. The best hospital I've seen is Northwestern Hospital
in Chicago.
What does your work at CARE Canada give you back?
It gives me a whole different perspective about the world, not in
health so much as global issues. I'm the Second Vice-Chair of the
Board of Trustees and Chair of the Finance Committee and have been
involved since 1994. We think of healthcare here as a huge problem,
but it's really very small compared to the AIDS pandemic in Africa,
so the work gives me an international perspective. I did volunteer
work in cancer care prior to this, but the global feeling and sense
I get with CARE Canada (www.care.ca) is important, and there are
differences - for example, in Zimbabwe with women's health and how
it's women who are turning their local communities around. This
work gives me the feeling of what it is to be a Canadian.
What book(s) are you reading?
I don't read anything serious at home, but when I do read, maybe at
night, a mystery or light reading. My husband and I are busy in the
summer with property and a pool, plus I keep fit, so I don't spend
a lot of time reading. I also garden a lot and find there's a great
sense of accomplishment in that, perhaps mirroring my work.
What's on your favourite t-shirt?
I only have one t-shirt, from a project team, with our slogan:
"Working well to the right solutions." But my favourite quote is,
"If you're going to be in a parade, be in the lead." For me it
fits, as in what we're doing at UHN - we're always leaders.
Acknowledgment
This profile made possible through an educational grant from Aramark Canada.Comments
Be the first to comment on this!
Personal Subscriber? Sign In
Note: Please enter a display name. Your email address will not be publically displayed