CIHI Survey: ED Spending in Canada: A Focus on the Cost of Patients Waiting for Access to an In-Patient Bed in Ontario
The intent of this article is to describe a method that can be used to determine the proportion of hospital spending and an estimated dollar value of spending in the ED that is associated with admitted patients waiting for access to an in-patient bed. Estimates at the provincial and Local Health Integration Network (LHIN) levels are provided. The method is based on financial and nursing workload reporting; it does not take into consideration issues external to the hospital that could impact costs such as availability of family physicians near the ED. Additional questions that need to be considered to more fully examine and understand ED costs are proposed in our conclusion.
Data Sources and Methods
All analyses reflect fiscal year 2005-2006. Pan Canadian rates of hospitalization via the ED (excluding those in Quebec) were determined from CIHI's Discharge Abstract Database. The Canadian Management Information Systems (MIS) Database (CMDB) holds financial and statistical data reported by healthcare organizations across Canada (including Quebec). Through the ability to use CMDB to link data from hospitals' clinical and financial databases, total spending on EDs, average cost per ED visit and the proportion of spending on admitted patients waiting in the ED were determined. Because data are submitted using the MIS standards chart of accounts, they are comparable across jurisdictions. ED volumes in Ontario were determined from CIHI's National Ambulatory Care Reporting System (NACRS).
Hospital costs reported in the ED include salaries for nurses and other staff, medical supplies and drugs and maintenance and operation of ED equipment. The cost of non-salaried physicians working in the ED and costs associated with laboratory tests and other diagnostics have not been included.
For provinces/territories outside of Ontario, cost per visit was estimated by dividing the costs charged directly to EDs by the number of ED visits as reported in the CMDB. For Ontario, costs per ED visit represents costs charged directly to EDs in the CMDB divided by the number of ED visits as reported in the NACRS. The portion of ED costs for patients who were admitted but waited in the ED for an in-patient bed were estimated by using nursing workload reported the hospitals. Workload in the ED is reported for both inpatients and outpatients and it is this split that allows the estimation of the cost associated with patients waiting for a bed. The estimates are only provided for Ontario since they are the only province that provides both nursing workload and NACRS data.
Provincial Spending on EDs
On average, provinces/territories spent about 4% of their hospital budgets on EDs (Figure 1). This ranged from $1.8 million in the Yukon to $791 million in Ontario. The average amount spent per ED visit was estimated to range from $73 in the Yukon (and < $100 per visit in the Maritime provinces) to $136 per visit in Saskatchewan to $148 dollars in Ontario. Variances may be due to ED staffing and operations and/or the type of hospital or community in which the ED is located.
Hospitals in Canada admitted 60% of patients via the ED, and half of these patients waited at least two hours in the ED for access to an in-patient bed. Hospitalization rates via the ED varied slightly across the provinces/territories, ranging from 56% in Nova Scotia to 77% in Nunavut. The average amount spent per ED visit and this hospitalization rate includes costs for admitted patients waiting in the ED for an inpatient bed. We were able to estimate this cost for Ontario; an estimated 6.5% of total ED spending (or $51 million) was dedicated to patients admitted via the ED.
ED Spending and Percentage Spent on Patients Admitted via the ED in Ontario's LHINs
Using CMDB and NACRS data for Ontario's EDs, we were able to take a closer look at regional variation in ED spending. Total spending on EDs was $791 million. This ranged from just over $25 million in Central West LHIN 5 to almost $90 million in Toronto Central LHIN 7 (Figure 2). On average, 10% of ED patients were admitted, with admission rates ranging from almost 7.6% in the South East LHIN 10 to almost 14% in Toronto Central LHIN 7. While there appears to be little relationship between total ED spending, the proportion of spending on patients admitted via the ED and hospitalization rates via the ED, there does appear to be regional variation that could be explored in greater detail.
Putting a Dollar Amount on Spending per ED Visit in Ontario
The average amount per ED visit in Ontario was estimated to be $148. This ranged from $111 per visit in the North East LHIN 13 to $219 per visit in Toronto Central LHIN 7 (Figure 3). When costs associated with admitted patients were removed, the average rate per visit dropped to $138 per visit, a drop of nearly 7%. While there does appear to be an association between the average amount spent per ED visit and the proportion of patients admitted via the ED, there appears be variation in the proportion spent on admitted ED patients.
What Else Needs to Be Considered?
This analysis provides a cursory exploration of the costs associated with patients waiting in the ED for access to an in-patient bed. The rates provided are simply estimates based on ED volumes, existing cost data and nursing workload in Ontario. There are many factors associated with ED costs and wait times that can be explored, such as in-patient bed capacity, hospital type and location, patient acuity, the size and staffing of EDs, hospital operational patterns and changes in the demand for hospital services (Bagust et al. 1999; Chan et al. 2001; Forster et al. 2003; Rathlev et al. 2007). With additional CMDB data, physician billing data and more in-depth analysis of NACRS or other provincial ED data, these factors could be considered in order to get a truer understanding of spending in the ED from a national perspective. While NACRS data is currently unavailable for provinces other than Ontario, CIHI has undertaken a redevelopment of NACRS that will allow all provinces to submit data with less reporting burden. The newly developed NACRS will provide more information on wait times and on patients flowing through the ED.
About the Author(s)
Heather Dawson, MHSc, is manager of health services research at the Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI). In this role, Heather oversees the development of health services analyses with the view to addressing relevant questions for policy and health systems issues. She has previously worked in leadership roles in hospitals and health planning and advocacy organizations in Ontario.
Greg Zinck, CA, is manager of management information systems and costing at CIHI. Greg oversees programs that update and maintain Canada's standards for reporting financial data from healthcare organizations, the Standards for Management Information Systems in Canadian Health Service Organizations, as well as data submitted to CIHI's Canadian MIS Database, which is based on that standard. His previous experience includes leadership roles in hospital finance departments and public accounting.
Bagust, A., M. Place and J.W. Posnett. 1999. "Dynamics of Bed Use in Accommodating Emergency Admissions: Stochastic Simulation Model." BMJ 319(7203): 155-58.
Bamezai, A., G. Melnick and A. Nawathe. 2005. "The Cost of an Emergency Department Visit and Its Relationship to Emergency Department Volume." Annals of Emergency Medicine 45(5): 483-90.
Bennett, K.J., C.G. Moore and J.C. Probst. 2007. "Estimating Uncompensated Care Charges at Rural Hospital Emergency Departments." The Journal of Rural Health 23(3): 258-63.
Canadian Institute for Health Information. 2007. Understanding Emergency Department Wait Times: Access to Inpatient Beds and Patient Flow. Ottawa: Author.
Chan, B., M. Schull and S. Schultz. 2001. Emergency Department Services in Ontario. Toronto: Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences.
Forster, A.J., I. Stiel, G. Wells, A.J. Lee and C. van Walraven. 2003. "The Effect of Hospital Occupancy on Emergency Department Length of Stay and Patient Disposition." Academic Emergency Medicine 10(2): 127-33.
Higginson, I. and H. Guly. 2007 "Payment by Results: A Guide for Emergency Physicians." Emergency Medicine Journal 24: 710-15.
Rathlev, N.K., J. Chessare, J. Olshaker, D. Obendorfer, S.D. Mehta, T. Rothenhaus, S. Crespo, B. Magauran, K. Davidson, R. Shemin, K. Lewis, J.M. Becker, L. Fisher, L. Guy, A. Cooper and E. Latvik. 2007. "Time Series Analysis of Variables Associated with Daily Mean Emergency Department Length of Stay." Annals of Emergency Medicine 49(3): 265-71.
Williams, R.M., 1996. "The Costs of Visits to Emergency Departments." New England Journal of Medicine 334(10): 642-46.
Be the first to comment on this!
Personal Subscriber? Sign In
Note: Please enter a display name. Your email address will not be publically displayed