Nursing Leadership

Nursing Leadership 22(3) October 2009 : 48-67.doi:10.12927/cjnl.2009.21154
Nursing Research

Effects of Leadership and Span of Control on Nurses' Job Satisfaction and Patient Satisfaction

Amy Sanchez McCutcheon, Diane Doran, Martin Evans, Linda McGillis Hall and Dorothy Pringle


Background: Hospital restructuring has resulted in nurse managers' having direct responsibility for a greatly expanded number of units and staff. However, very little research has examined the impact of these larger spans of control on nurse and patient outcomes.

Objective: This study examined the relationships between leadership style, span of control, nurses' job satisfaction and patient satisfaction, as well as the moderating effect of span of control on the relationship between leadership style and the two outcomes.

Methods: The study was conducted at seven teaching and community hospitals with a sample of 51 units, 41 nurse managers, 717 nurses and 680 patients. Data analyses included multiple regression and hierarchical linear modelling.

Results: The study findings provided support for the theoretical relationships among leadership style, span of control, nurse job satisfaction and patient satisfaction. In addition, the results showed that higher spans of control decreased the positive effects of transformational and transactional leadership styles on job satisfaction and patient satisfaction, and increased the negative effects of management by exception and laissez-faire leadership styles on job satisfaction.

Discussion: Leadership matters, and certain leadership styles, particularly transformational, are better than others. Span of control also matters: the wider the span, the lower the nurses' job satisfaction and patient satisfaction. However, as spans of control increase in size, no leadership style, even transformational, can overcome the negative effects.



Be the first to comment on this!

Note: Please enter a display name. Your email address will not be publically displayed